Commit Graph

4 Commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
Xavier Morel
8e67aed792 [IMP] runbot_merge: limit spamming on PR close
When closing a PR, github completely separates the events "close the
PR" and "comment on the PR" (even when using "comment and close" in
the UI, a feature which isn't even available in the API). It doesn't
aggregate the notifications either, so users following the PR for
one reason or another get 2 notifications / mails every time a PR
gets merged, which is a lot of traffic, even more so with
forward-ported PRs multiplying the amount of PRs users are involved
in.

The comment on top of the closure itself is useful though: it allows
tracking exactly where and how the PR was merged from the PR, this
information should not be lost.

While more involved than a simple comment, *deployments* seem like
a suitable solution: they allow providing links as permanent
information / metadata on the PRs, and apparently don't trigger
notifications to users.

Therefore, modify the "close" method so it doesn't do
"comment-and-close", and provide a way to close PRs with non-comment
feedback: when the feedback's message is structured (parsable as
json) assume it's intended as deployment-bound notifications.

TODO: maybe add more keys to the feedback event payload, though in my
      tests (odoo/runbot#222) none of the deployment metadata
      outside of "environment" and "target_url" is listed on the PR
      UI

Fixes #224
2019-11-21 08:10:39 +01:00
Xavier Morel
3ce3dd9569 [IMP] forwardbot: show FP PRs in reminder message
When posting a reminder that there are open / waiting forward ports on
a source PR, also post *which* PRs those are.

While at it, move the cron code in a proper python file (so we can use
stuff from odoo.tools), and fix display_name so we can straight use
display_name as a github ref' ({owner}/{repo}#{number}). This impacts
log-grepping but it seems like an improvement nonetheless.

Closes odoo/runbot#228
2019-10-11 09:13:55 +02:00
Xavier Morel
c5d68c20f4 [IMP] forwardport: add feedback when being wrong
User should probably be warned when they try to set the limit ("up
to") in a context where it's going to be ignored:

* on a forward port PR (should be set on the source)
* on a merged source (should be set before the PR is merged)

Closes #213
2019-10-02 17:49:54 +02:00
Xavier Morel
01ff6d13db [IMP] forwardport: move limits tests into their own file
test_simple is starting to get pretty big and we'll need some more
tests for #213
2019-10-02 17:49:54 +02:00