Commit Graph

4 Commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
Xavier Morel
f8da17994a [FIX] forwardport: not being properly notified on last FP of a seq
If the default limit of a forward-port sequence is not a valid
target (either disabled or not actually forward-ported to), the last
effective forward port in a sequence will be commented on as any
intermediate PR rather than get a proper ping and r+ instructions.

Also remove a bunch of leftover prints in the tests.

Fixes #192
2019-09-16 15:07:40 +02:00
Martin Trigaux
48c8e53df2 [FIX] forwardport: clarify forward port message
The ping message was not clear
- don't know if anything is needed from the author
- don't know if the last step in the chain

Ping the authors only when something needs to be done (error or last
step).

Do not ping non-reviewers as they will not have the rights to r+ or
modify the PR anyway

Closes #192
2019-09-12 09:05:49 +02:00
Xavier Morel
a69ed7996a [FIX] forwardport: change method for conflicting working copy
The original method was to `git diff | git apply` in order to get a
complete overview of conflicts generated by the forward port (if
any).

However this turns out to have a huge issue in the presence of renamed
or removed files: in that case `git apply` will simply not do
anything, and fail with a completely clean working copy. Which is very
much undesirable.

-> alternative method, squash the PR to a single commit then
cherry-pick that single commit, this should provide us with proper
conflicts & their markers.

Also add tests for conflicts due to deleted files...
2019-09-12 09:05:49 +02:00
Xavier Morel
f671dcc828 [ADD] forwardbot
* Cherrypicking is handrolled because there seems to be no easy way to
  programmatically edit commit messages during the cherrypicking
  sequence: `-n` basically squashes all commits and `-e` invokes a
  subprocess. `-e` with `VISUAL=false` kinda sorta works (in that it
  interrupts the process before each commit), however there doesn't
  seem to be clean status codes so it's difficult to know if the
  cherrypick failed or if it's just waiting for a commit of this step.

  Instead, cherrypick commits individually then edit / rewrite their
  commit messages:

  * add a reference to the original commit
  * convert signed-off-by to something else as the original commit was
    signed off but not necessarily this one

* Can't assign users when creating PRs: only repository collaborators
  or people who commented on the issue / PR (which we're in the
  process of creating) can be assigned.

  PR authors are as likely to be collaborators as not, and we can have
  non-collaborator reviewers. So pinging via a regular comment seems
  less fraught as a way to notify users.
2019-09-05 10:00:07 +02:00